Thursday, 17 September 2020

On the Need to Distinguish Knowledge of Essential Properties from the Knowledge That They Are Essential

In one of my favourite papers about modal metaphysics, Rosen's 'The Limits of Contingency', Rosen develops the idea that there are two sets of modal notions which are apt to be conflated under the heading 'metaphysical modality'. Roughly: a correct conceivability modality, and a more properly metaphysical modality on which some things which are correctly conceivable are in any case not really possible.


In a recent paper, 'Correct Conceivability and its Role in the Epistemology of Modality' whichin a new book Les Principes Métaphysiques published by the College de France, Robert Michels considers an objection to Rosen's idea of a correct conceivability modality construed as giving an account of how considerrations about conceivability can takes us from non-modal to modal knowledge. I think this objection is based on a misunderstanding, as I will explain in this post. 


Let me quote from Michels, first to set the scene, and then to see the objection and the main responses Michels considers.

Correct Conceivability

The basic idea

10The correct conceivability-approach presupposes the Kripkean standard view of metaphysical modality and accordingly has to rule out modal errors, cases in which a state of affairs is conceivable, but not metaphysically possible. How this is done is nicely explained in the following mock-quote of Rosen’s “others”:

If the ancients could conceive a world in which water is an element, this is only because they were ignorant of certain facts about the natures of things. In particular, it is because they did not know what it is to be water. They did not know that to be water just is to be a certain compound of hydrogen and oxygen – that to be a sample of water just is to be a quantity of matter predominantly composed of molecules of H2O. This is not to say that they did not understand their word for water. But it’s one thing to understand a word, another to know the nature of its referent. The ancients could see no contradiction in the supposition that water is an element because they did not know that water is a compound by its very nature. But we know this; and given that we do, we can see that to suppose a world in which water is an element is to suppose a world in which a substance that is by nature a compound is not a compound. And that’s absurd. (Rosen 2006, p. 22-23)

11The idea is hence that in order to avoid modal error, conceivability needs to be supplemented by knowledge of the natures, or equivalently, essences of relevant entities, in this case the essence of (the property of being) water. Equipped with this knowledge, the conceiver is able to detect that the assumption that water is an element together with essential truths about the relevant entity entails an absurdity.

12The correct conceivability-approach hence gives us a simple and elegant explanation of why we are apt to make modal errors and a recipe for ruling them out. We tend to commit modal errors because we can conceive of states of affairs which are ruled out by relevant essences. To avoid these errors, we have to let our ability to conceive be guided by knowledge of the essences of relevant entities.

An objection to essence-based conceivability approaches and how it can be addressed

13There is a rather obvious objection to the correct conceivability-approach which should be mentioned: The approach crucially relies the conceiver having knowledge of essence, but essence itself is a modal notion. Doesn’t this mean that the notion of correct conceivability cannot answer the core question of modal epistemology, the question of how we can acquire modal knowledge?

  • 5 See for example Lowe (2012), Hale (2013, ch. 11), Tahko (2016), Tahko (2017). For a recent critical (...)

14


(End of quote.) 


Michels considers a number of responses, but not the following simple one which I think is correct.


Yes, the approach relies on the conceiver knowing that some thing has a property, where arguably that property is in fact an essential property of the thing. But the approach does not rely on the conceiver knowing that the thing essentially has that property.

The idea is not that people learned that water is essentially H2O and then on that basis, saw that water being simply an element is not correctly conceivable. Rather, they just learned that water is H2O, and then on the basis of their grasp of how the concept of water works, saw that water being an element is not correctly conceivable. The knowledge of essence, just like the knowledge of necessity (Fine taught us to disinguish the two), may perhaps also be accounted for along similar lines. But that's by the by. This objection simply doesn't get off the ground as far as I can see. 


This sort of confusion is not unique to Michels's paper. Phrases like 'knowledge of essence' and 'knowledge of necessity' are apt to blur this important sort of distinction, leading to mistakes in the epistemology of modality. 


References

Michels, Robert. Correct Conceivability and its Role in the Epistemology of Modality In : Les principes métaphysiques [en ligne]. Paris : Collège de France, 2020 (généré le 18 septembre 2020). Disponible sur Internet : <http://books.openedition.org/cdf/8079>. ISBN : 9782722605350. DOI : https://doi.org/10.4000/books.cdf.8079.

Rosen, Gideon (2006). The limits of contingency. In Fraser MacBride (ed.), Identity and Modality. Oxford University Press. pp. 13--39.

42 comments:

  1. I still don’t know the right words to express my gratitude to this great man Dr. Uromi. After been diagnosed of HERPES SIMPLEX VIRUS in 2months ago, i was given so many health prescription and advice with no improvement, I totally lost hope, until i found testimonies of Great Dr. Uromi online research and on Facebook, Like anybody would be, I was very skeptical about contacting him, but i later did and he opened up to me and told me what was involved and he started the remedies for my health. Thank God, I was cured from herpes by the herbal medication I received from him. I never thought that herpes can be cured, from the bottom of my heart I'm truly grateful,i pray you have long life so you can help many more people on earth with your herbal medical support, You can Email him via email Druromiherbalhome@gmail.com or for easy and fast communication you can also call or add him on whats-app with this mobile number +2349021374574 , one thing i love most about DR Uromi is honestly, and he is very polite with his patience, everything he told me was what he did, and his herbal medicine are very affordable  

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Herbal medicine is the best Greetings I am here to testify how great man called Dr OMO helped me out with herbs and roots which he prepared for me in use of curing my fibroids and Getting pregnant after 8 years of try to conceive with fibroids I takes his product (cure for my fibroid made with herbal medicine Root) for (14) days before I am to known I was totally pregnant after 2months of  using dr omo herbs he also  have Herbal medical for all types of diseases, and i promised him that i will tell the world about his Great job he ask me to drink from the herbal medicine before meeting my husband I did and after 2months I was pregnant thank you for your great job he can also help you  if you have a low sperm count  you want to  convince a baby fast  PCOS ,infections, stomach ucler , Endometriosis, infertility tea breast cancer,HIV?AID, yeast infection,  Gonorrhea, Chronic Sinus, HPV1&2, Asthma, low testosterone, Herpes, blocked fallopian tubes, Liver parasites ovarian Arthritis, Cysts, pile, Diabetes, Epilepsy,ALS, Crowns and all other type of  diseases, cancer, Get lost period back, stop period pain, Email : dromo596@gmail.com WhatsApp him on +2349033505260 thank you dr omo
      How can i ever stop saying thank you to Dr omo

      Delete
  2. I can’t believe this. A great testimony that i must share to all HERPES SIMPLEX VIRUS patient in the world i never believed that their could be any complete cure for Herpes or any cure for herpes,i saw people’s testimony on blog sites of how dr Ero prepare herbal medicine that cure and brought them back to life again. i had to try it too and you can,t believe that in just few weeks i started using it all my pains stop gradually and i had to leave without the pills the doctor gave to me. Right now i can tell you that few months now i have not had any pain,delay in treatment leads to death. Here is his email:(wealthylovespell@gmail.com) whatsapp him with +2348105150446 visit blog http://wealthyspellhome.over-blog.com

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hello views, join me to appreciate Dr. Uromi for the great work he did for me, that has been my happiest day in my life. This true life story you should pick up a point. I have been diagnosed with herpes virus for years,I’ve lost all hope and that there is no cure and I haev been taking medicine to sustain myself till I got to know about Dr. Uromi through a friend who he cured of herpes. I contacted him and he sent me his herbal remedy which I took as he directed me to do for some days and I went to the hospital after consuming his Herbal medicine and I was confirmed herpes Negative after years of pains and suffering , it is indeed a miracle, Dr. Uromi is a great man, I have heard so much about how he has help lot of people, if you have any issue you can contact him for help.via email him on. Druromiherbalhome@gmail.com  you can as well call his mobile number or add him on whatsapp +2349021374574..  

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi.. I am searching that kind of blog which I found it. And I thanks too you bfor sharing please visit on Mcafee kundensupport

    ReplyDelete
  5. hi, your post is very helpful for me. Finally, I found exactly what i want. If you need information regarding antivirus then you can visit our site Lenovo ondersteuning belgie

    ReplyDelete
  6. Your blog is very informative, finally, I found exactly what I want. Paypal is an excellent service for online payments but lots of its users confront issues while they access Paypal. If you want to resolve your problems then must visit Paypal ondersteuningsnummer.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Your blog is very informative and interesting to read, finally, I found exactly what I searching for. There are lots of users of Macfee antivirus in the world because of its features and easy interface. If you want to explore more interesting facts about Mcafee antivirus or want to resolve your technical issues then must visit bellen Mcafee Nederland.

    ReplyDelete
  8. hi, your post is very helpful for me. Finally, I found exactly what i want. If you need information regarding printers then you can visit our site problemen yahoo mail

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hi, Thank you for sharing such a good and valuable information,It is very important for me. Gmail is the worldwide used email service but sometimes user faces some problems in it. If you want to get some information about the Gmail then you can visit Gmail asiakaspalvelu suomi.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thanks for sharing it is important for me. I also searched for that from here. Visit our site Lenovo ondersteuning

    ReplyDelete
  11. hi, your post is very helpful for me. Finally, I found exactly what i want. If need information regarding printers then you can visit our site Contacto Bullguard

    ReplyDelete
  12. Hi read your blog amazing techniqe and amazing information. I found that kind of blog which is now I got it.More info please visit on total av deutsch

    ReplyDelete
  13. Hi read your blog amazing techniqe and amazing information. I found that kind of blog which is now I got it.More info please visit on Bellen Avast

    ReplyDelete
  14. Hi.. I read your blog which is really gud or amazing. Please visit on Mcafee support deutschland

    ReplyDelete
  15. Hi.. I read your blog which is really gud or amazing. Please visit on facebook bellen

    ReplyDelete
  16. , I was diagnosed of herpes virus, I have tried all possible means to get cure but all my effort proved abortive, until a friend of mine introduced me to a herbal doctor called Dr Agaba, who prepare herbal medicine to cure all kind of diseases including herpes virus (Herpes), when i contacted this herbal doctor via email, he sent me herpes virus herbal medicine via courier service, when i received the herbal medicine he gave me step by step instructions on how to apply it, when i applied it as instructed i was totally cured from the virus within 3 weeks of usage. Contact this great herbal doctor today to get your cure. 
    Via Email: Dragabasolutionhome@gmail.com or WhatApp: +2349074536486  

    ReplyDelete
  17. I Can't still believe that i got cured from Genital Herpes through herbal treatment from Dr agaba who I met through the internet, I actually couldn't believe it at first because it sounded impossible to me knowing how far I have gone just to get rid of it. Dr agaba send me his medicine which I took as instructed and here I am living a happy life once again, a big thanks to Dr agaba, I am sure there are many herbal doctors out there but Dr agaba did it for me, contact him Dragabasolutinhome@gmail.com , also call or whatsApp him on +2349074536486  

    ReplyDelete
  18. hi I read your blog which is really great.Please visit on this site.bellen total av

    ReplyDelete
  19. I want to share my testimony how Dr Agbomian cure my HERPES☘ virus am very happy today that am 🍀now herpes nagative person I Never believe this before please cantact him.💖 he is a great healer. Message him on🌿 WhatsApp/Call +2347040843115 or Email address:💓 dragbomianherbalcured77@gmail.com❤

    ReplyDelete
  20. Hi your post is really appreciatable.I really thankful for this post. Here i would llike to share some information about facebook. As we know that facebook is a social trap where we connect with people in all over world. So if you are using facebook and face any technical issue that time so just visit our website. We can resolve the smallest problem on same time. For further information please visit on our website- facebook telefoonnummer

    ReplyDelete
  21. Hi thankyou for this great helpful information.this information is really useful at today's time.you had easily explained whole information in a short note. Now i would like to share some information about PayPal.So If you are a Paypal user and you are facing any problem regarding to PayPal. No need to worry just simply visit on our site- paypal email belgie

    ReplyDelete
  22. hi, your post is very helpful for me. Finally, I found exactly what i want. If you need information regarding bullguard antivirus then you can visit our site Servicio al cliente Bullguard

    ReplyDelete
  23. hi, your post is very helpful for me. Finally, I found exactly what i want. If you need information regarding yahoo mail then you can visit our site yahoo mail gratis mail

    ReplyDelete
  24. Really Nice Post Admin, Very helpful looking for more posts, Now I have to share some information about How To Fix “Lenovo Troubleshooting Guide” problem. If you are going through this problem you can simply visit Lenovo ondersteuning

    ReplyDelete
  25. *Herpes is a serious and recurring disease which can't be cured through drugs or injections by the American doctors but the best way to deal with Herpes is by taking natural herbs medicine for it and is only few American doctors that know about this herbal medicine from Dr oliha.. I have read about Dr oliha the great herbalist doctor from African who can cure Herpeewith his powerful herbal medicine. for the people suffering from the following diseases Hiv, Herpes, Cancer, Als,Herpatitis, Diabetes, Hpv,Infections ETC should contact him for his herbal medicine because i am a living testimony and i was cured of Herpes. Although, i sent him what he requested and he sent me his medicine which i took for two weeks and today when i went for test i was tested Herpes negative and he can also cure herpes etc you can reach him through his WhatsApp number:+2349038382931 he will help you out or email oliha.miraclemedicine@gmail.com or https://olihamiraclemedicine.webs.com/ *

    ReplyDelete
  26. Thanks for sharing it is important for me. I also searched for that from here. Visit our site Lenovo ondersteuning

    ReplyDelete
  27. hi, your post is very helpful for me. Finally, I found exactly what i want. If you need information regarding Lenovo laptop then you can visit our site yahoo helpdesk belgie

    ReplyDelete
  28. hi, your post is very helpful for me. Finally, I found exactly what i want. If you need information regarding Netflix then you can visit our site netflix ondersteuningsnummer

    ReplyDelete
  29. Always, anywhere and anytime, I feel very comfortable now all to the work of Dr Idedia, the Herbalist who prepare for me the remedies to my health challenges. i could feel more comfortable when he explained to me how dangerous it's caring Herpes simplex virus (HSV1&2) with me getting affected easily with Other sexually transmitted infections. Genital sores increases my risk of transmitting or contracting other sexually transmitted infections, including AIDS.
    Newborn infection. ...am a lover who ran into it and had a shock on me after the checkup.
    This has been my earnest prayers for the physician therapist to come in with positive solutions to remedies Herpes and most
    Bladder problems. ...
    Meningitis. ...
    Rectal inflammation (proctitis).
    I was so scared when he says that because I fault viral infections. I'm now free and I thank God for leading me to see others getting cured with Herbs. I decided to try and found out that the best way I would have done was to get rid of it and give my testimony. Glory to God I became free from herpes after I received his medicine from the FEDEX and applied as instructed. Till date I had no SYMPTOMS nor virus to detect of me, I called him and thankful for what he did, and ask if he could cure HPV, he said yes and did the same preparation to my friend for her hpv virus and Recovered from it. Nothing is impossible with Herbs IN CURES, you're the next if you will be willing to apply his medicine and instructions on how to manage.
    Sickness has no right to dwell on us, you can reach him at his email address
    For your immediate response to health. kindly contacted Dr Idedia  WhatsApp  +2349074505296 or E-mail:  dr.idediatraditionalhealinghome@gmail.com visit his websites  https://dr-idedia-traditional-healing-home9.webnode.com/ Or https://sites.google.com/view/dridediatraditionalhealinghome/ Or
       https://dr-idedia-traditional-healing-home.business.site/  

    ReplyDelete
  30. Really Nice Post Admin, Very helpful looking for more posts, Now I have to share some information about How To Fix “google Troubleshooting Guide” problem. If you are going through this problem you can simply visit google support Nederland

    ReplyDelete
  31. Really Nice Post Admin, Very helpful looking for more posts, Now I have to share some information about How To Fix “yahoo mail Troubleshooting Guide” problem. If you are going through this problem you can simply visit yahoo mail bellen

    ReplyDelete
  32. I Want To Appreciate Dr OLIHA for his great deeds, I Was Diagnosed With type 2 Herpes Virus Last year, And I Was Looking For Solution To Be Cured Luckily I Saw Testimonies On How Dr OLIHA Cure Herpes Virus I Decided To Contact Dr OLIHA I Contacted Him He Prepared A Herbal Medicine Portion And Sent It To Me, I Started The Herbal Medicine For My Health. He Gave Me Step By Step Instructions On How To Apply It, When I Applied It As Instructed, I Was Cured Of This Deadly Herpes Within 2 weeks, I Am Now Herpes Negative. My Brother And Sister I No That There Are So Many People That Have The Same Herpes Virus Please contact Dr OLIHA To Help You Too, And Help Me To Thank Dr OLIHA For Cure Me, I’m Cured By Dr. OLIHA Herbal Medicine, His Contact Email:{oliha.miraclemedicine@gmail.com} or visit his website is https://olihamiraclemedicine.webs.com/  or  Cell Whatsapp Number +2349038382931 thank you

    ReplyDelete
  33. Thanks for sharing it is important for me. I also searched for that from here. Visit our site Lenovo ondersteuning

    ReplyDelete
  34. Hi.. I read your blog which is really great. If you are facing technical issues of Avast Antivirus visit on bellen avast nederlands

    ReplyDelete


  35. If you are infected with Herpes I recommend that you contact Dr Irene and get herpes cure made with natural root and herbs that cures herpes simplex virus within 14 days. My partner and i were once positive with genital herpes Dr Irene saved us. Contact him via email Email: dr.ireneherbalhome@gmail.com Whatsapp/Call: +2348078793935 or +2348164800591

    ReplyDelete
  36. Hello everyone. Dr Ishiaku herbs is a good remedy for herpes Virus , I was a carrier of herpes virus and I saw a testimony on how Dr. Ishiaku cure Herpes Virus, I decided to contact him, I contacted him and he guided me. I asked him for solutions and he started the remedies for my health. After he finish he sent me the herbs which i took for 2 weeks before asking me to go for a check up and getting there i could not believe that i was confirm HSV 2 Negative after the test, Today i am so happy because i'm free from herpes disease with the help of Dr. Ishiaku . Thank God now everything is fine, I'm cured by Dr. Ishiaku herbal medicine, I'm very thankful to God for making it possible. you can reach him on his email, i strongly recommend him to any one out here looking for a cure to herpes or any other deadly disease...Contact Dr ishiaku via email: ishiakuherbalcure@yahoo.com or whatsapp +234818082844

    ReplyDelete
  37. Herbal medicine is the best Greetings I am here to testify how great man called Dr OMO helped me out with herbs and roots which he prepared for me in use of curing my fibroids and Getting pregnant after 8 years of try to conceive with fibroids I takes his product (cure for my fibroid made with herbal medicine Root) for (14) days before I am to known I was totally pregnant after 2months of  using dr omo herbs he also  have Herbal medical for all types of diseases, and i promised him that i will tell the world about his Great job he ask me to drink from the herbal medicine before meeting my husband I did and after 2months I was pregnant thank you for your great job he can also help you  if you have a low sperm count  you want to  convince a baby fast  PCOS ,infections, stomach ucler , Endometriosis, infertility tea breast cancer,HIV?AID, yeast infection,  Gonorrhea, Chronic Sinus, HPV1&2, Asthma, low testosterone, Herpes, blocked fallopian tubes, Liver parasites ovarian Arthritis, Cysts, pile, Diabetes, Epilepsy,ALS, Crowns and all other type of  diseases, cancer, Get lost period back, stop period pain, Email : dromo596@gmail.com WhatsApp him on +2349033505260 thank you dr omo
    How can i ever stop saying thank you to Dr omo

    ReplyDelete
  38. hello viewers all over the globe am very happy today to share my testimony on how i was cure from HERPES disease, i have been suffering from herpes for the pass 9 months which makes me had constant pain all over my body, i have went to several hospitals taking treatment from doctors, but still know improvement till i meet a old friend of mine who direct me to a great traditional herbalist called Dr Akioya  which i contacted by email so luckily he reply back i explain my problem to him and he told me not to worry that his going to prepare the herbal medicine and send to me which will cure me forever, i believed in him, after all the procedures given to me by Dr Akioya few weeks later i went to see my doctor to confirm if i was finally cure, the result was positive am totally cured by this great herbalist my life is more important now am free and happy if you have such sickness or any kind of disease like HIV And AIDS, Diabetes, Epilepsy, Blood Cancer, HPV, ALS, Hepatitis A/B, pregnancy issues etc contact Dr Akioya  details: drakioya17spellhome@gmail.com or call +2348105257464 i will forever be grateful

    ReplyDelete
  39. I have been suffering from (HERPES SIMPLEX VIRUS) disease for the past four years and had constant pain. During the first year, I had faith in God that i would be healed someday.This disease started circulating all over my body and i have been taking treatment from my doctor, few weeks ago i came on search on the internet if i could get any information concerning the prevention of this disease, on my search i saw a testimony of someone who has been healed from Herpes Simplex Virus by this by Dr voodoo and she also gave the email address of this man and advise anyone to contact him for any kind of problem that he would be of help, so i wrote to Dr voodoo telling him about my (Herpes Virus) he told me not to worry that i was going to be cured!! Though i never believed it,, well after all the procedures and remedy given to me by this man few weeks later i started experiencing changes all over me as the Dr voodoo assured me, after some time i went to my doctor for test and it confirmed that i have be finally healed behold it was TRUE, So friends if anyone have such problem and need help contact Dr voodoo on his email: voodoospelltemple66@gmail.com Add Dr voodoo on whatsApp +2348140120719

    ReplyDelete
  40. RELIABLE HERPES CURE BY HERBALIST RAZOR. I am here to share how a great man called Herbalist Razor helped me out with herbs and roots which he prepared for me in use of curing herpes. I took his product (cure) for (18) days before I was totally cured out of it, and I promised him that I will testify my healing to the whole world about how he cured me which I am very happy to be fulfilling. Doctor Razor also cures all kinds of diseases , HEPATITIS, CANCER, DIABETICS , FIBROID. Reach him on Email address  drrazorherbalhome@gmail.comWebsite :  https://herbalistrazorherb.wixsite.com/drrazorherbalhome Contact him on Whtasapp +2349065420442

    ReplyDelete
  41. RELIABLE HERPES CURE BY HERBALIST RAZOR. I am here to share how a great man called Herbalist Razor helped me out with herbs and roots which he prepared for me in use of curing herpes. I took his product (cure) for (18) days before I was totally cured out of it, and I promised him that I will testify my healing to the whole world about how he cured me which I am very happy to be fulfilling. Doctor Razor also cures all kinds of diseases , HEPATITIS, CANCER, DIABETICS , FIBROID. Reach him on Email address  drrazorherbalhome@gmail.comWebsite :  https://herbalistrazorherb.wixsite.com/drrazorherbalhome Contact him on Whtasapp +2349065420442

    ReplyDelete